Subject: [IGSREPORT-2658] Wk 0851 NCL GNAAC Analysis Report
From: Phil Davies
Date: Thu, 16 May 1996 11:08:27 PDT

******************************************************************************
IGS Electronic Report    Thu May 16 11:08:27 PDT 1996      Message Number 2658
******************************************************************************

Author: Phil Davies
Subject: Wk 0851 NCL GNAAC Analysis Report

 =SCR 2.01 NCL 96:137:52477 COM 96:117:43200 96:125:43140
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DESCRIPTION A-Sinex comparison report, gps week 0851
OUTPUT      NCL (Surveying Dept., Univ of Newcastle upon Tyne, England)
CONTACT     Phil Davies ([email-masked])
SOFTWARE    TANYA
HARDWARE    HP 730
INPUT       cod  emr  esa  gfz  jpl  sio  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1) Notes
The NCL G-Sinex with stated constraints removed is COMB in the tables below
CORE is the 13-station constraining subset, ITRF94 coordinates
This report format is under development - more to come, comments welcome
Ad hoc variance scaling factors applied
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2) Input and output Sinex in NCL analysis for week 0851

Type  Agency   Filename____   Sinex_ID________
  A     cod    cod08517.snx   COD 96:130:26700        
  A     emr    emr08517.snx   NRC 96:130:49620        
  A     esa    esa08517.snx   ESA 96:134:64622        
  A     gfz    gfz08517.snx   GFZ 96:130:54720        
  A     jpl    jpl08517.snx   JPL 00:000:00000        
  A     sio    sio08517.snx   SIO 96:131:32059        

  G     NCL    ncl0851g.snx   NCL 96:137:50753
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3) Common station set sizes

           cod     emr     esa     gfz     jpl     sio    COMB    CORE
  cod       71      27      52      47      39      59      71      12
  emr               30      27      26      24      26      30      12
  esa                       58      44      38      53      58      12
  gfz                               50      34      46      50      12
  jpl                                       51      43      51      10
  sio                                               68      68      11
 COMB                                                       90      12
 CORE                                                               12

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4) Postfit residuals St Devs (mm) with far-outliers removed

          emr      esa      gfz      jpl      sio     COMB     CORE  
  cod     23.18    27.52    14.87    16.95    14.26     8.70    12.29
  emr              36.29    13.57    32.44    13.74    17.76    12.96
  esa                       34.49    26.41    30.89    27.57    29.50
  gfz                                27.62    12.32    12.22    11.93
  jpl                                         19.59    12.00     8.25
  sio                                                   8.01     9.94
 COMB                                                            8.45

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5) Postfit residuals Weighted RMS (mm) with far-outliers removed

          emr      esa      gfz      jpl      sio     COMB     CORE  
  cod     19.18    11.76     8.90    17.82     9.57     5.41     6.06
  emr              22.06    12.18    27.01    10.43    15.77    13.63
  esa                       13.47    16.82    13.28    11.71    11.36
  gfz                                22.69     8.85     9.45     8.39
  jpl                                         21.01    17.59     9.24
  sio                                                   5.79     8.59
 COMB                                                            4.83

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6) 7 parameters from A-Sinexes to COMB

             Tx        Ty        Tz        S         Rx        Ry        Rz
             (m)       (m)       (m)                (rad)     (rad)     (rad)

    cod    7.87E-03  3.52E-02 -1.66E-02  9.28E-10 -8.59E-08  4.28E-09 -1.17E-07
     sd    5.73E-06  6.00E-06  8.36E-06  2.44E-10  1.59E-08  1.45E-08  1.78E-08

    emr    6.07E-03 -9.53E-02  1.04E-01 -3.64E-09  2.52E-07 -1.64E-08 -3.12E-08
     sd    1.30E-05  1.51E-05  4.23E-05  4.73E-10  9.16E-08  7.71E-08  1.02E-07

    esa    3.06E-03  2.80E-02  4.42E-02  3.29E-09  2.42E-07 -9.85E-09  7.30E-06
     sd    1.62E-05  1.57E-05  5.71E-05  8.04E-10  8.40E-08  8.40E-08  8.02E-08

    gfz    8.95E-03 -1.73E-01  5.68E-02 -9.02E-10  2.42E-07 -9.00E-09 -3.10E-08
     sd    9.89E-06  8.37E-06  3.78E-05  4.01E-10  2.68E-08  2.41E-08  6.21E-09

    jpl   -2.02E-03  3.88E-02 -7.14E-03  1.40E-09  2.36E-07  2.76E-08 -1.70E-07
     sd    6.52E-06  6.21E-06  7.86E-06  2.17E-10  7.22E-07  7.05E-07  7.02E-07

    sio   -1.08E-02  3.01E-02  8.64E-03 -1.27E-09  2.54E-07 -1.13E-08  9.51E-09
     sd    6.68E-06  6.19E-06  2.11E-05  1.88E-10  6.21E-08  5.95E-08  6.10E-08

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7) 7 parameters from A-Sinexes and COMB to CORE

             Tx        Ty        Tz        S         Rx        Ry        Rz
             (m)       (m)       (m)                (rad)     (rad)     (rad)

    cod    8.92E-03 -1.72E-02  4.03E-02  1.29E-09 -3.33E-07  9.41E-09 -8.60E-08
     sd    7.08E-06  7.16E-06  9.52E-06  5.12E-10  1.59E-08  1.45E-08  1.78E-08

    emr    1.69E-02 -1.41E-01  1.36E-01  5.99E-10  5.32E-09 -9.65E-09 -8.98E-10
     sd    1.54E-05  1.75E-05  4.69E-05  7.25E-10  9.16E-08  7.71E-08  1.02E-07

    esa   -8.04E-03 -3.61E-02  1.21E-01  1.07E-09 -3.48E-09 -5.24E-09  7.33E-06
     sd    1.81E-05  1.73E-05  6.87E-05  1.50E-09  8.40E-08  8.40E-08  8.02E-08

    gfz    2.34E-02 -2.29E-01  9.90E-02  1.43E-09 -5.54E-09 -1.32E-09  2.65E-10
     sd    1.20E-05  1.02E-05  4.64E-05  7.33E-10  2.68E-08  2.41E-08  6.23E-09

    jpl    6.21E-03 -8.40E-03  5.98E-02  1.80E-09 -1.24E-08  3.28E-08 -1.39E-07
     sd    7.23E-06  6.91E-06  8.48E-06  4.42E-10  7.22E-07  7.05E-07  7.03E-07

    sio   -2.94E-03 -1.63E-02  5.72E-02  9.06E-10  5.72E-09 -5.13E-09  3.92E-08
     sd    8.09E-06  7.45E-06  2.52E-05  4.04E-10  6.21E-08  5.95E-08  6.10E-08

   COMB    9.14E-03 -4.98E-02  5.54E-02  1.22E-09 -2.48E-07  6.35E-09  3.02E-08
     sd    3.64E-06  3.52E-06  5.52E-06  2.20E-10  1.28E-08  1.18E-08  5.80E-09

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8)Station sets and discrepancies with NCL station catalogue

Each station in this week's A-Sinexes is listed below. For each AC estimating
each station, a six-character report is given.  The meaning of each character
and its possible states are as follows:
Char 1: inclusion in combination: i = included, X = excluded
Char 2: DOMES code info         : - = given
                                  d = not given and not known by NCL
                                  D = not given but listed in NCL catalogue
Char 3: ANTENNA information     : - = matches NCL catalogue or not given
                                  a = text string discrep. (type and/or S/N)
                                  A = vector discrep. (phase centre) > 1mm
Char 4: RECEIVER information    : - = matches NCL catalogue or not given
                                  r = text string discrep. (type, S/N or firm)
Char 5: ECCENTRICITY info         - = matches NCL catalogue or not given
                                  E = vector discrep. (local tie) > 1mm
Char 6: RESIDUAL size             - = not yet implemented

Important Note! The NCL catalogue is compiled and updated from past Sinex
submissions - when discrepancies exist, the catalogue uses the most popular
(among ACs) value for each data item. The catalogue is therefore simply a
method of comparing solutions, and is not authoritative. If most ACs are
flagged as discrepant on the same item, the catalogue is probably wrong.

The codes are chosen so that '-' means no problem, a lower-case
letter means a less important discrepancy, and an upper case letter means an
important one. ACs with upper case codes - please modify your Sinex blocks, or 
email me to put me right! Suggestions about this section are welcome.

Codes 'a' and 'r' should be diregarded by Centres not yet using the v1.00
20-character description strings.

SITE PT SOLN DOMES____ _cod__ _emr__ _esa__ _gfz__ _jpl__ _sio__ 

ALBH  A    1 40129M003 i-a--- i----- i-----        i----- i-a--- 
ALGO  A    1 40104M002 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
ANKR  A    1 20805M002 i-----        i-----               i-a--- 
AREQ  A    1 42202M005 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
ASC1  A    1 ---------                             id----        
AUCK  A    1 50209M001 i-----        i-----               i----- 
BOGT  A    1 41901M001 i-----        i----- i-a---        i-a--- 
BOR1  A    1 12205M002 i-----        i-----               i-a--- 
BRMU  A    1 42501S004 i-----        i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
BRUS  A    1 13101M004 i-----                      i----- i-a--- 
CAS1  A    1 66011M001 i-----        i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
CHAT  A    1 50207M001 i-----        i-----        XD---- i----- 
CHUR  A    1 ---------        id----                             
CRO1  A    1 ---------                             id---- id---- 
DAV1  A    1 66010M001 i-----        iD---- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
DRAO  A    1 40105M002 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
EISL  A    1 41703M003 i-----               i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
FAIR  A    1 40408M001 i----- i--rE- i--rE- i-ArE- i----- i-a--- 
FORT  A    1 41602M001 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
GODE  A    1 40451M123 i-----                                    
GOL2  A    1 ---------                             id---- id---- 
GOLD  A    1 40405S031 i----- i--r-- i----- i-a---               
GOPE  A    1 11502M002 i-a---                                    
GRAS  A    1 10002M006 i-----                                    
GRAZ  A    1 11001M002 i-----                             i-ar-- 
GUAM  A    1 50501M002 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
HART  A    1 30302M002 i--r-- i--r-- i----- i-ar-- i----- i-Ar-- 
HERS  A    1 13212M007 i-----                             i-ar-- 
HKLO  A    1 ---------                             id----        
HOB2  A    1 50116M004 i-----               i-a---        i-a--- 
IISC  A    1 22306M001 X----- X-ArE- X--r-- X-arE- XD---- X-a-E- 
IRKT  A    1 12313M001 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- iD---- i-a--- 
JOZE  A    1 12204M001 i-a---                             i-a--- 
JPLM  A    1 40400M007                      i-a--- iD---- i-a--- 
KELY  A    1 43005M001               i-----               i-a--- 
KERG  A    1 91201M002 i-a--- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-ar-- 
KIRU  A    1 10403M002               i-----        iD---- i----- 
KIT3  A    1 12334M001 i----- X----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
KOKB  A    1 40424M004 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
KOSG  A    1 13504M003 i--r-- i--r-- i--r-- i--r-- i----- i-ar-- 
KOUR  A    1 97301M210 i-----        i----- i-a---        i-ar-- 
KWJ1  A    1 ---------                             id---- id---- 
LAMA  A    1 12209M001 i--r--                                    
LHAS  A    1 21613M001               iD----                      
LMNO  A    1 ---------                             id----        
LPGS  A    1 41510M001 i-a---        iD---- i-a--- iD---- iDa--- 
MAC1  A    1 50135M001 i-----        i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
MADR  A    1 13407S012 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-ar-- 
MALI  A    1 33201M001 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- iD---- i-ar-- 
MAS1  A    1 31303M002               i--r-- i-ar-- iD----        
MASP  A    1 31303M001 i--r--                             i-ar-- 
MATE  A    1 12734M008 i-----        i----- i-----        i-ar-- 
MCM4  A    1 66001M003 i----- i----- i---E- i-a-E- i----- i-a-E- 
MDO1  A    1 40442M012 i-----        i----- i-a---               
MDVO  A    1 12309M001 i-a---                      i-----        
METS  A    1 10503S011 i-----        i----- i-a---        i-a--- 
MOIN  A    1 ---------                             id----        
NLIB  A    1 40465M001 i-----               i-ar--               
NOTO  A    1 ---------                             id---- id---- 
NRC1  A    1 40114M001        i-----                             
NYAL  A    1 10317M001 i-----        i----- i-----        i-arE- 
ONSA  A    1 10402M004 i-----        i----- i-a---        i-a--- 
PAMA  A    1 92201M003 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
PERT  A    1 50133M001 i-----        i-----        i----- i-a--- 
PIE1  A    1 40456M001 i-----        i-----        i-----        
POL2  A    1 12348M001 i-a---        i--r--        iD---- i-a--- 
POTS  A    1 14106M003 i-----               i-a---        i-a--- 
QUIN  A    1 40433M004 i-----                                    
RCM5  A    1 40499S018 i-a--- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
REYK  A    1 10202M001 i-----        i--r--        iD---- i-a--- 
SANT  A    1 41705M003 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-ar-- 
SHAO  A    1 21605M002 i-----        i-----               i-a--- 
STJO  A    1 40101M001 i-a--- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
TAEJ  A    1 23902M001 i-----                             i-a--- 
TAIW  A    1 23601M001 i----- i----- i--r-- i-ar--        i-ar-- 
THU1  A    1 43001M001 i--r--        i--r-- i-a--- iD---- i-a--- 
TID2  A    1 ---------                             id----        
TIDB  A    1 50103M108 i----- i----- i----- i-ar--        i-ar-- 
TROM  A    1 10302M003 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-ar-- 
TSKB  A    1 21730S005 i-a--- i--r-- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
UPAD  A    1 12750M002 i-a---                                    
USUD  A    1 21729S007 i-----        i----- i-ar-- i----- i-a--- 
VILL  A    1 13406M001               i-----               i----- 
WES2  A    1 40440S020 i-a---        i----- i-a---        i-a--- 
WETT  A    1 14201M009 i-----               i-a---        i-ar-- 
WILL  A    1 40134M001        i-----                             
WTZR  A    1 14201M010 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- iD---- i-a--- 
YAR1  A    1 50107M004 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-ar-- 
YELL  A    1 40127M003 i----- i----- i----- i-a--- i----- i-a--- 
ZIMM  A    1 14001M004 i-a---                             X-a--- 
ZWEN  A    1 12330M001               i----- i-a---        i-a--- 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[Mailed From: "P.B.H. Davies" <[email-masked]>]